Going home Danny Noriega Kady Malloy Asia'h Epperson Luke Menard Top 12 David Archuleta Carly Smithson Brooke White Syesha Mercado Ramiele Malubay David Cook David Hernandez Jason Castro Chikezie Amanda Overmyer Kristy Lee Cook Michael Johns Ryan Seacrest Paula Abdul Simon Cowell Randy Jackson Nigel Lythgoe